Skip to content
Patrick Marren
Patrick Marren

Author

  • Fatal Certainty – Coming Soon
  • Fatal Certainty – The Thesis
  • Blog
  • Biography – Patrick B. Marren
  • Contact & Links
  • Patrick Marren Video Clips
Patrick Marren

Author

the ruins of the temple of apollo

Introduction: Fatal Certainty

admin, August 15, 2023August 18, 2023

Fatal Certainty: The Cult of Prediction and the Need for a New Way to Deal with Fundamental Future Uncertainty

Since ancient times, human beings have craved certainty. Two and a half millennia ago, rulers facing life-and-death decisions sought guidance from prophets and oracles; closer to our own time, astrologers such as Nostradamus were in high demand. The western Enlightenment brought a new approach to uncertainty: the scientific method of trial and error, which proved spectacularly effective in rendering previously inexplicable phenomena both understandable and predictable. 

Centuries of steady scientific progress have greatly increased the sphere of knowledge and the predictive powers of human beings. Yet that very progress has created the illusion that essentially everything important to humans is, or soon will be, predictable. The relatively new field of probability, which arose alongside the scientific revolution, has added another layer to this certainty. Even that which cannot be known with certainty, probability seems to say, can be predicted to within an acceptable level of uncertainty. 

Fatal Certainty makes the argument that this sanguine attitude toward future uncertainty is unjustified. The remaining sphere of strictly unpredictable phenomena, in fact, is far closer to what it was in the days of the Oracle of Delphi than most people realize. 

The first two decades of the third millennium have demonstrated this fact over and over. The terrorist attacks of 2001; the “cakewalk” of the Iraq War that turned into anything but; the global financial crisis of 2008; and the COVID pandemic of 2020-present were not just the result of bad luck. In important respects, they were all either made possible, or made far worse than they should have been, by a fatally arrogant expert certainty that assumed that the phenomena of terrorism, war, finance, and epidemiology were all so well-understood that outcomes could be predicted with certainty, and catastrophe in these areas was therefore unthinkable. 

One might think that disasters such as these would cause experts to search for new ways to deal with what must now be acknowledged as radically uncertain, yet still strategically critical, phenomena. Unfortunately, for the most part this has not been the case. The response instead has been to double down on prediction, particularly on numerical forecasting approaches – even in areas in which prediction is either impossible or useless for planning. 

Fortunately, there is another approach to dealing with fundamental uncertainty: rigorous imagination. Fatal Certainty makes an inarguable case for human beings and institutions getting much, much better at this discipline – before it is too late. 

Forecasting Rigorous Imagination The Cult of Prediction

Post navigation

Previous post
Next post

Related Posts

Algorithms basketball hoop in basketball court

Games Beyond Edges?

September 15, 2023September 15, 2023

September 15, 2023  Bruce Schoenfeld’s Game of Edges: The Analytics Revolution and the Future of Professional Sports traces the impact of numerical analysis on sports, from the Moneyball days of the 1990s Oakland Athletics; through the 2000s curse-breaking Boston Red Sox; to Liverpool Football Club’s use of predictive analysis; to the NBA Golden…

Read More
Algorithms File cabinet clipart, office furniture

“The Data Delusion” vs. Rigorous Imagination

August 15, 2023August 18, 2023

July 20, 2023 Jill LePore is a Harvard historian whose wide-ranging scholarship has embraced the broad sweep of American history (These Truths), Native American-colonial conflict (The Name of War), superheroes (The Secret History of Wonder Woman), and even the Beatles (introduction to Paul McCartney’s 1964: Eyes of the Storm).   In her…

Read More
Forecasting Dynamic Earth - Ocean Currents

Even Some “Scientific” Stuff Requires Alternative Scenarios: El Niño Edition

November 11, 2023November 11, 2023

Every day brings more proof that the range of strategically critical phenomena that are utterly unable to be predicted is almost as vast as it was in the day of Brian Rua U’Cearbhain or the Oracle of Delphi. Today, the Washington Post shows us that even when the vast majority…

Read More
©2026 Patrick Marren | WordPress Theme by SuperbThemes